I've got a lot to say about who's in my Fav Five, so I'm gonna go position-by-position. On some points I'll agree with my bodacious wife with amazing sports knowledge, but on others I'll definitely disagree.We'll start with the point guard position, where I definitely disagree. Hope you enjoy!
Point GuardHow can you go wrong with Magic? The man redefined the point guard positions and brought "Showtime" to the Lakers. Who could I possibly choose over Magic? Well, for my money, I'll go with The Big O, Oscar Robertson.This guy was arguably the best all-around player to ever play the game, let alone the best point guard. How easilywe forget the greats who played before our own lifetime...

The Big O averaged a triple-double per game over his first five seasons. Let me repeat that:
The Big O averaged a triple-double per game over his first five seasons. Here'show it breaks down:
30.3 points, 10.6 assists, and 10.4 rebounds per game! Can you even comprehend that? Everyone wants to crown Lebron as "King James" just 'cuz he's had a few years of 25+points, 7+ assists, and 7+ rebounds... I can't even imagine the hoopla Lebron would get if his statlines had him upwards of 30/10/10 over his career to date, and yet everyone seems to sleep on The Big O. And let me also point out that it's more difficult for a point guard to pull down 10 boards a night than it is for a point forward to dish out 7 assists a night. I know, there's no need for me to compare Oscar and Lebron in this forum since we're breaking it down by position, but I just want to emphasize how little recognition The Big O gets compared to his inferior modern-day counterparts.
And lest you think Oscar's greatness halted after his first five years, here are his per-game statsover his first ten years:
29.3 points, 10.3 assists, and 8.5 rebounds. Again, putting this in perspective, during the playoffs last year, everyone was going googly over Chris Paul reaching 30 points and 10assists so many times... yet The Big O averaged 29+ points and 10+ assists over his first 10 years. Not 10 games... 10 freaking years. Whoa. My brain is on overload just trying to imagine if a modern-dayplayer was putting up these numbers.
So back to the Magic comparison... Magic was obviously a phenomenal point guard--second only to The Big O. However, I think his greatness is artificially supplemented by the following factors: 1) Magic has 5 championship rings, whereas The Big O only has 1 ring. But let me remind you that Magic's 5 rings represent that his
team was the best
team five times. Idon't think Oscar's one ring disqualifies him from this race... it only means his
team was the best
team only once. And let's remember that Magic played with all-time greats Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Bob McAdoo, Jamaal Wilkes, James Worthy, Norm Nixon, Michael Cooper, Byron Scott, AC Green, etc. The Big O wasn't so fortunate... I bet you can't even name one of his teammates during his prime (anyone guess Jerry Lucas, Tom Van Arsdale, or Jack Twyman? Didn't think so). Funny thing is, once Oscar passed his prime, he finally got a chance to play with a great teammate--Kareem Abdul-Jabbar with the Milwaukee Bucks in 1971. And guess what, they won a championship! Imagine the damage Oscar and Kareem could have done playing together for as long as Magic and Kareem... Besides the lack of quality teammates, Oscar's career just happened to coincide with the greatest dynasty in professional sports history--the 1960s Boston Celtics. In The Big O's 15-year career, the Celtics won 9 titles, including 8 out of 9 during The Big O's 10-year prime. As great as he was, even he couldn't beat out a team laden with all-time greats up and down the roster. Let's put it this way, if we put Oscar on the 1980s Lakers, they win AT LEAST five rings, probably more. If we put Magic on the 1960s Cincinnati Royals, I guarantee he's not winning championships against Red Auerbach & Co. Thus, we give Oscar a pass on the championship ring tally. 2) Magic played more recently. 3)Magic played a brand of basketball that came to be known as "Showtime", played in an era when television coverage of the NBA was exploding, and played for the New York Yankees... oops, I mean the LA Lakers; these combined elements gave him a disproportionate amount of publicity and fanfare.
Oscar was a better scorer. Oscar was a better rebounder. I'll give them a push on the passing (Magic was certainly a more "showtime" passer, but I've noticed his turnovers were relatively high, resulting in a pretty mediocre assist-to-turnover ratio as far as great point guards go. Magic doesn't even reach the prerequisite 3-to-1 threshold, while guys like John Stockton and Chris Paul are pushing 4-to-1. Unfortunately, turnovers were not tracked in Oscar's day, so we can't directly compare). I never got to see Oscar play defense, and steals and blocks were not tracked in his day, so I can't speak to Oscar's defense. But given the phenomenal athlete he was, I'm imagining he was a great defender. Magic was a good defender too, often raking in the steals, but he's not known for his great two-way abilities in the same way guys like MJ, Tim Duncan, Wilt, Bill Russell, and others are. By default, I have to give them another "push" on defense.
All things considered, I'll take The Big-O to run the show in My Fav Five.
Honorable Mention: Magic Johnson, Isiah Thomas
Watch Out For: Chris Paul